The Same Score, This Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, 2nd Movement
Definitive recordings of the ‘Allegretto’ compared by tempo, accents, reverberation, and ensemble size
This list connects eight actual recordings, from Carlos Kleiber and Karajan to Arnoncourt, Gardiner, Kurenchi, Dudamel, Bernstein, and Petrenko. Since all are interpretations of the same Movement II, the focus can be placed on the differences in performance rather than the piece itself. Given the disparities in sound quality and recording dates, we won’t determine superiority based purely on tempo; instead, we will specifically compare string articulation, accents, resonance, and cumulative climaxes.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Carlos Kleiber & Vienna Philharmonic
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Carlos Kleiber & Vienna Philharmonic” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphonies Nos. 5 & 7, introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Carlos Kleiber & Vienna Philharmonic” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Carlos Kleiber & Vienna Philharmonic” are Vienna Philharmonic & Carlos Kleiber, and the release year is 1995; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it in this list only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Carlos Kleiber & Vienna Philharmonic,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of the list.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Karajan & Vienna Philharmonic
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Karajan & Vienna Philharmonic” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphony No. 7 & Haydn: Symphony No. 104, introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Karajan & Vienna Philharmonic” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Karajan & Vienna Philharmonic” are Vienna Philharmonic & Herbert von Karajan, and the release year is 1959; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Karajan & Vienna Philharmonic,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of this list.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Bernstein & New York Philharmonic
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Bernstein & New York Philharmonic” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphony No. 7 in A Major, Op. 92 (Remastered), introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Bernstein & New York Philharmonic” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Bernstein & New York Philharmonic” are Leonard Bernstein & New York Philharmonic, and the release year is 1960; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it here only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Bernstein & New York Philharmonic,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of this list.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Harnoncourt & Chamber Orchestra of Europe
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Harnoncourt & Chamber Orchestra of Europe” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphonies Nos. 1-9, introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Harnoncourt & Chamber Orchestra of Europe” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Harnoncourt & Chamber Orchestra of Europe” are Nikolaus Harnoncourt & Chamber Orchestra of Europe, and the release year is 1991; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Harnoncourt & Chamber Orchestra of Europe,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of this list.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Gardiner & Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Gardiner & Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphony No. 7, Op. 92 & No. 8, Op. 93, introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Gardiner & Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Gardiner & Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique” are Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique & John Eliot Gardiner, and the release year is 1994; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Gardiner & Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of this list.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Currentzis & musicAeterna
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Currentzis & MusicAeterna” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphony No. 7 in A Major, Op. 92, introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Currentzis & MusicAeterna” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Currentzis & MusicAeterna” are Teodor Currentzis & MusicAeterna, and the release year is 2021; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Currentzis & MusicAeterna,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of the list.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Dudamel & Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Dudamel & Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphonies Nos. 5 & 7, introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Dudamel & Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Dudamel & Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra” are Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra of Venezuela & Gustavo Dudamel, and the release year is 2006; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it here only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Dudamel & Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of the list.
Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Petrenko & Berlin Philharmonic
The Symphony No. 7: II. Allegretto track linked to “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Petrenko & Berlin Philharmonic” is an actual recording from the album Beethoven: Symphony No. 7, introduced as the “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Petrenko & Berlin Philharmonic” entry to fit the selection criteria of “The Same Score, So Different: Eight Performances of Beethoven's Seventh, Second Movement.” The performers listed on Apple Music for “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Petrenko & Berlin Philharmonic” are Kirill Petrenko & Berlin Philharmonic, and the release year is 2020; since this date may differ from when Ludwig van Beethoven wrote the work, we use it here only as recording information. When looking for other versions of the same work as “Beethoven Symphony No. 7, 2nd Movement — Petrenko & Berlin Philharmonic,” check the title, performers, and album together so you don't confuse the same recording with a reissue, and so you can also see the context of the list.
The connected release years are taken from the respective audio editions shown on Apple Music. For historical recordings, take care not to confuse the remastering year with the actual recording date. Once you’re comfortable comparing, try broadening your scope to the first or fourth movements to see how the same conductor designs the entire rhythm-centered symphony. The purpose of this list is to distinguish interpretations you'd like to revisit based on circumstances rather than simply picking the best performance.
As part of the Coupang Partners program, this post may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
Comments 0
Log in to leave a comment.
Be the first to comment.
How about these lists?
You might also like
Not ready to stop here?
Wondering what to read next is the biggest waste of time.
Let the dice decide — you won't know what pops up until you roll.
If you don't press it… won't you wonder forever? 👀