Those Who Waited for the Return in Ithaca
An Introduction to Characters Read Through Relationships and Actions of Those Who Kept and Dismantled a House Without a King
The homecoming in the Odyssey doesn't unfold only at sea. While Odysseus stays on Calypso's island, in the palace of Ithaca the suitors squander his wealth and press Penelope to marry. Telemachus has to win back control of the household without even knowing whether his father is alive or dead. The Ithaca story at the beginning of the work first shows the reader why the homecoming is needed. In this article, we compare the different roles, from Penelope to Phemius.
Those who wait can't be lumped together under a single attitude, either. Penelope buys time and tests the truth with her weaving and the test of the bed, while Telemachus grows into an adult who takes action through his journey. Eumaeus and Philoetius stay loyal while their master is away, but Melanthius and Melantho side with the suitors. Within the same house, choices diverge. We also offer a guide for reading the events of the original text separately from later interpretations.
This list covers not only the family and the loyal servants but also the leading suitors, the servants who betrayed the household, and the bard who was forced to sing. It doesn't justify the ancient patriarchal order and violent punishment in the name of loyalty, and it looks at the scope of action and the risks each character faced. It's a character guide for comparing for whom the homecoming scenes work as restoration and for whom they work as judgment. Rather than memorizing names, look at how choices and consequences carry over into the next scene.
Penelope
Telemachus
Eumaeus
Eurycleia
Argos
Laertes
Antinous
Eurymachus
Melanthius
Melantho
Philoetius
Phemios
Examining the characters of Ithaca reveals that even when Odysseus arrives on land, the return has not ended. He receives Eumaeus' hospitality, plans with Telemachus, and is recognized by Eurycleia through his scar. In the end, Penelope and Laertes confirm identities through shared memories. The home is restored not as a place but through the recognition of relationships. Instead of memorizing names, we observe how choices and results lead to the next scenes.
The distinction between loyalty and betrayal must also consider the characters' status and power relationships. The servants are not modern citizens free to choose a king and had to survive during the long periods when the suitors occupied the palace. While the story clearly contrasts Eumaeus and Melanthius, one should not overlook the reflection of the class and gender order in ancient society when reading punishment scenes. The criteria for reading the original events and later interpretations are also presented.
When reading again, let’s mark the order of who recognizes Odysseus and when. Argos recognizes him immediately, Eurycleia identifies him by his scar, and Penelope rejects hasty acknowledgment, bringing forth the secret of the bed. Each mode of recognition reveals the lives that character shared with the protagonist. The Ithaca section is both the conclusion of a long voyage and another adventure testing memory and trust. In this text, we compare the different roles from Penelope to Phimius.
As part of the Coupang Partners program, this post may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
Comments 0
Log in to leave a comment.
Be the first to comment.
How about these lists?
You might also like
Not ready to stop here?
Wondering what to read next is the biggest waste of time.
Let the dice decide — you won't know what pops up until you roll.
If you don't press it… won't you wonder forever? 👀